Leiden Law Blog

AG of European Court of Justice rains on Dutch file sharing parade

Posted on by Bart Schermer in Private Law , 1
AG of European Court of Justice rains on Dutch file sharing parade

The Netherlands has been a paradise for file sharers for many years now. But this could very well change quite soon. Last week, Advocate General to the European Court of Justice mr. Cruz Villalon issued his opinion on the case of ACI versus Thuiskopie (case c-435/12). In the opinion Cruz-Villazon slammed the Dutch government for allowing downloading from an illegal source.

I deliberately say ‘downloading from an illegal source’ rather than ‘illegal downloading’, because downloading files from an illegal source is currently not considered an infringement of copyright by the Dutch government. This interpretation dates back to Parliamentary questions asked by MP Arda Gerkens of the Socialist Party in 2002. Her question to the Minister of Justice was whether downloading from an illegal source (e.g. an illegal upload to a file sharing site) was also covered by the home copying exception. The Minister answered that this was indeed the case. As such, copying a file (downloading), even if the source is an illegal upload, is not considered an infringement of copyright. Hence, Dutch downloaders can download music, movies and books at their leisure, without fear of prosecution.

Whenever a homecopy is made however, the copyright holder must be compensated. In the Netherlands this is done via a levy on physical carriers (e.g. blank DVDs). The makers of these blank media weren’t very happy with this, went to court and ultimately ended up before to the Dutch Supreme Court. The question that was put before the ECJ by the Dutch Supreme Court was whether in the height of the compensation copies made from an illegal source should also be taken into account. To answer this question the ECJ must first answer whether the Dutch interpretation is actually in line with article 5(5) of the EU Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC).

Article 5(5) of the Directive sets out the requirements under which an exception to copyright is allowed in the national laws of the Member States. The formula used is based on the Berne Convention on Copyright and is called the ‘3 step test’. A copyright exception is only allowed under national law if:

  1. the exception shall only be applied in certain special cases;
  2. the exception does not interfere with the normal exploitation of the work; and
  3. does not unreasonably prejudice the legitimate interests of the rightsholder.

According to Cruz Villalon, the Dutch interpretation fails the second step… hard. In his words:

“The Kingdom of the Netherlands indirectly but inevitably contributes to the massive distribution of copyrighted material, which in itself cannot be considered normal and is in fact the very cause of the problem that the member state tries to solve via the levy system… …Trivialising the issue of downloading from an illegal source cannot have any other consequence than that normal exploitation is disrupted.”

If the ECJ follows the conclusion of the Advocate General, the file sharing party in the Netherlands is over. Downloading will become illegal same as in the rest of the world and the rightsholders can go after downloaders with full force.

1 Comment

Google news - World
Posted on June 19, 2015 at 12:34 by Google news - World

Canada and various countries in Africa offer the operation, the Sydney local headed to a shady retreat under a tree to chat to her friend.Meanwhile the blonde stunner recently revealed she has decided to join Michelle Bridges’ 12-week body transformation challenge alongside her co-star David ‘Kochie’ KochAfter the personal trainer asked Samantha live on air to take part in the three-month challenge the star tentatively agreed: ‘I??ll do it If you do it [Kochie]‘She then added: ‘I??ll just have a little champagne on Sunday’On Friday night the Australian Women’s Weekly cover girl took to Instagram to show her dedication to the cause uploading a photo of her newly-installed veggie garden?Posting a photograph of her DIY creation she wrote alongside a leaf emoticon: ‘Vegie garden planted Think I need a wine.‘In the snap a collection of plants like basil and lettuce can be seenSamantha, In rare cases.‘Another wrote: ‘Everyone’s all upset over the game and I’m still laughing over the left shark who didn’t know his dance moves.Her fiery outfit earned quick comparisons online to the late US professional wrestler Bam Bam Bigelow who wore outfits with hot-rod style flames along with a large flame tattoo on his head.Others promptly pointed out that Katy resembled Chester Cheetah - the official mascot for Cheetos snacksHer entrance to others also evoked memories of Peter Griffin riding a lion in an episode of the animated comedy The Family GuySome also thought the outfit was similar to the ice skating costume worn by Will Ferrell in his 2007 comedy Blades Of Glory?Things can go up and down in football really quickly as I discovered at Norwich.Things change If someone goes and someone else comes in [Chris Hughton was replaced by Neil Adams in April] with a different mindset your situation changesYou can see the difference between the way it was and the way it is But I’ve dealt with it It??s now in the past and I don??t want to go in to the situation again It is part of my careerOf course it was disappointing to see Norwich relegated and I was sad not to play in the games near the endAs regards the future I don??t want to think about it When the time comes I will talk about it I am just enjoying playing regularly I am grateful for the chance and I want to be 1000 per cent focused for Watford? but as players you have to cope with it and the squad here has coped really well. January 29By Published: 19:01 GMT.
Google news - World http://capitalclubdk.winweb02.abusiness.dk/hajime9773.asp?//Google_News_-_World.html

Add a Comment

Name (required)

E-mail (required)

Please enter the word you see in the image below (required)

Your own avatar? Go to www.gravatar.com

Remember me
Notify me by e-mail about comments